AMD Trinity im Test: Alle Desktop-APUs im GPU-Vergleich

6/11

21.11.2012 13:00 Uhr

Weitere Testreihen

GPU-Computing

Moderne Grafikkarten und damit auch die APUs können deutlich mehr Berechnungen ausführen als nur für eine 3D-Grafik. Mittlerweile gibt es schon zahlreiche Programme, die den 3D-Beschleuniger für andere Aufgaben nutzen und damit der CPU in diesen Gebieten Konkurrenz machen. Doch wie gut können Grafikkarten diese Aufgaben in der Praxis erledigen? Das finden wir anhand einiger theoretischen und praxisnahen Tests heraus. Als Programmierschnittstellen kommen dabei Direct Compute und OpenCL zum Einsatz.

Civilization V

Leader Benchmark:
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  111,8
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  109,9
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  92,4
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  90,9
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  82,4
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  74,3
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  50,3
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  41,5
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  38,1

Einheit: Bilder pro Sekunde (FPS)

CLBenchmark

Physics:
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  2.310
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  2.308
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  2.060
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  2.051
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  1.894
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  1.376
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  1.321
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  1.214
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  1.085
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  856
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  560
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  534
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  524
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  519
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  518
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  411
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  380
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  355
Graphics:
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  29.456
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  24.396
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  22.016
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  21.165
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  16.319
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  16.275
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  14.668
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  12.360
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  11.354
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  8.457
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  8.400
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  8.104
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  7.455
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  7.279
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  7.154
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  6.653
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  3.390
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  2.641
Vision:
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  1.378
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  1.159
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  1.134
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  1.117
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  1.110
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  1.016
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  832
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  726
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  498
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  495
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  485
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  477
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  455
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  352
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  285
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  269
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  0
  
  Nicht möglich
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  0
  
  Nicht möglich
Image Filter:
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  122.658
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  120.233
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  104.243
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  97.872
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  93.533
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  62.311
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  49.755
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  37.934
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  21.779
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  15.914
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  9.657
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  7.122
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  6.854
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  6.719
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  6.710
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  4.641
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  4.414
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  4.151
Programming Principles:
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  17.708
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  17.445
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  17.108
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  13.836
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  13.463
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  12.699
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  12.691
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  10.263
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  8.421
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  6.709
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  5.894
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  5.408
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  5.302
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  4.905
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  4.340
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  4.150
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  4.099
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  4.087

Einheit: Punkte

DX SDK FluidCS11

64K Partikel, Grid+Sort:
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  101,6
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  101,5
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  83,4
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  80,2
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  80,2
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  71,1
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  61,4
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  42,5
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  38,4
16K Partikel, Shared Memory:
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  13,8
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  13,2
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  12,8
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  10,1
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  9,3
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  9,3
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  7,2
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  4,7
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  3,2

Einheit: Bilder pro Sekunde (FPS)

Luxmark

Simple Scene:
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  2.455,0
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  1.974,0
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  1.925,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  1.905,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  1.595,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  1.595,0
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  1.587,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  1.587,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  1.524,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  1.490,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  1.472,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  1.455,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  1.233,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  960,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  887,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  838,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  737,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  703,0
Medium Scene:
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  405,0
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  238,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  229,0
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  222,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  214,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  212,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  206,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  203,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  178,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  170,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  166,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  166,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  127,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  105,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  100,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  84,0
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  67,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  46,0
Complex Scene:
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  261,0
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  135,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  129,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  128,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  128,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  125,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  112,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  97,0
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  97,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  96,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  76,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  76,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  67,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  64,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  60,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  40,0
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  39,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  30,0

Einheit: Punkte

SiSoft Sandra

Single Precision:
- AMD A10-5800K @ GPU
  
  643,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ GPU
  
  609,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ GPU
  
  500,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ GPU
  
  409,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ GPU
  
  409,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ GPU
  
  308,0
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ GPU
  
  252,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ GPU
  
  196,0
- Intel Core i7-3770K @ CPU
  
  158,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ GPU
  
  87,0
- Intel Core i3-3220 @ CPU
  
  70,0
- AMD A10-5800K @ CPU
  
  64,0
- AMD A10-5700 @ CPU
  
  60,0
- AMD A8-5600K @ CPU
  
  60,0
- AMD A8-5500 @ CPU
  
  56,0
- AMD A8-3870K @ CPU
  
  41,0
- AMD A6-5400K @ CPU
  
  30,0
- AMD A4-5300 @ CPU
  
  29,0

Einheit: MIPS

Beim GPU-Computing hat AMD die Konkurrenz meistens im Griff, solange die Software über eine gute GPU-Unterstützung verfügt. Dann schlagen die Trinity-APUs den Core i3-3200 durchweg und auch der Core i7-3770K muss sich meistens geschlagen geben. Auffällig ist erneut der starke Einbruch der Ein-Modul-APUs, vor allem der A4-5300 verliert teils völlig den Anschluss.

Bei reiner CPU-Beschleunigung können die Prozessoren von Intel hingegen fast immer ihre Stärken ausspielen und lassen die Trinity meistens hinter sich.